Changing Accountant · Catch-Up
Accountant Not Replying or Holding Your Records? What to Do (UK 2026)
Quick answer: you do not need your old accountant’s permission to move on. A new accountant can be authorised with HMRC straight away and can see what has and has not been filed, and most missing records can be rebuilt from bank statements and HMRC data. Records that belong to you should be handed over when you ask; professional guidance only lets an accountant hold some back in narrow cases linked to unpaid fees. Your filing deadlines do not pause while you sort it out, so act now.
This happens more often than people think. The accountant who did your accounts for years stops answering the phone, a deadline goes past, a penalty letter arrives, and when you ask for your paperwork nothing comes back. This guide covers what to check first, what you are entitled to, how to protect yourself from further penalties and how to get every year back up to date.
1. Check the public record and your HMRC accounts to see what is actually overdue. 2. Ask for your records in writing, with a deadline. 3. Appoint a new accountant; they do not need the old one’s agreement. 4. Keep filing: Companies House only extends deadlines for events outside your control, and you must apply before the deadline. 5. Rebuild anything missing from bank statements and HMRC data, oldest year first.
Step 1: find out what has actually been filed
Do not rely on what you were told. You can check most of it yourself in ten minutes, and it shows the real size of the problem.
Where to check what is outstanding
| Company accounts and confirmation statement | The free Companies House register: search the company, open “Filing history”. Overdue items are flagged on the overview page. |
| Corporation Tax, VAT and PAYE | Your HMRC business tax account shows returns received, returns outstanding, any HMRC estimates and the balance owed. |
| Self Assessment | Your HMRC personal tax account or the HMRC app shows which tax years have a return outstanding and any penalties charged. |
| Letters | Gather every HMRC and Companies House letter, even unopened ones. Penalty notices and estimates show dates that matter. |
Step 2: your records, and who they belong to
Your own documents, such as bank statements, sales and purchase invoices, receipts and contracts, belong to you. So, in general, do the books and records an accountant keeps on your behalf. The working papers they prepare for their own file are usually theirs.
ICAEW’s Code of Ethics requires an outgoing accountant to deal promptly with any reasonable request to transfer records. ICAEW’s guidance says an accountant can only hold back (exercise a “lien” over) property that belongs to the client, only where specific conditions are met, and that this is rarely possible with a company client, and never over its statutory books or accounting records. The purpose is to encourage payment of a fee that is genuinely due for that work, not to win a fee dispute.
If there is an unpaid bill, ask for a clear statement of what is owed. Paying an undisputed amount is often the quickest way to get your records moving.
Step 3: ask for them properly
- Send the request in writing (email is fine), list exactly what you need and give a reasonable deadline such as 14 days.
- If your bookkeeping software (for example Xero or QuickBooks) is in your name, log in yourself and remove their access. If it is in theirs, ask for the file to be transferred to you.
- Ask for copies of the last returns filed, the latest trial balance, and your HMRC and Companies House authentication details if they hold them.
- When you appoint a new accountant, they send a professional enquiry letter to the old one as a matter of course. You do not have to have the awkward conversation yourself.
Step 4: deadlines do not stop while you wait
This is where most of the damage is done. Penalties keep building whether or not your accountant replies, so the priority is getting returns filed, not winning the argument.
- Companies House will only extend an accounts deadline for an event outside your control. Its examples are an unexpected illness, or a fire destroying records shortly before the deadline. You must apply before the deadline. Problems with an accountant are not among the examples, so do not count on an extension.
- HMRC lists “you relied on someone else to send your return, and they did not” as something that may be a reasonable excuse for a late filing penalty. The law says relying on someone else only counts if you also took reasonable care yourself, for example by chasing progress, so keep every email and note of calls.
- Whatever the excuse, HMRC expects the return to be sent as soon as you are able.
Our guide to appealing an HMRC penalty with a reasonable excuse explains how an appeal is put together.
Step 5: if they have disappeared altogether
Anyone in the UK can call themselves an accountant. If yours belongs to a professional body such as ICAEW, ACCA, AAT, ATT or CIOT, you can check their membership on that body’s public register and complain to it. If their mistakes have cost you penalties or extra tax, take legal advice on whether a claim against their professional indemnity insurance is worth making.
None of that has to hold up your filings. A new accountant can rebuild what is needed without the old files.
How missing records are rebuilt
Bank statements are the backbone. Your bank can supply several years of them, and every sale and expense passes through them. We combine those with HMRC data (payments made, returns received, PAYE and CIS records), Companies House filings, sales platform reports and any invoices you still hold. Where something genuinely cannot be found, we make a reasonable estimate, record how it was worked out and tell you before anything is filed.
We then work oldest year first, because each year’s closing figures become the next year’s opening figures.
A real enquiry from November 2026
In November 2026 a company director contacted us after finding that the company’s VAT returns had not been submitted for four years. For a case like that we get authorised as the company’s agent, pull the VAT account to list every missing period and any HMRC estimates, rebuild the figures from bank statements and invoices, and file the oldest period first. Then we check every penalty, appeal where there is a genuine case, and move the company onto a simple quarterly routine so it does not happen again. Our late VAT returns service sets out how it works.
What it costs to put right
At Your Tax Help Accountants a catch-up is quoted as one fixed project fee, in writing, before any work starts. It is typically £400 to £10,000, depending on how many years are outstanding, how many returns are involved and how much has to be rebuilt. See our catch-up accounting service and how we handle a switch of accountant for you.
Let down by your accountant? Book a free 15-minute call and we will tell you exactly what is outstanding and what it will cost to fix.
Book a free call →Free · No obligation
Let down by your accountant? Tell us what is outstanding
Tell us what has not been filed and which letters you have. We reply the same day with what is needed and a fixed fee.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my accountant refuse to give me my records?
Generally not. Records that belong to you should be handed over when you ask. ICAEW guidance only allows an accountant to hold back client property in narrow circumstances linked to a fee genuinely owed for that work, and says this is rarely possible with a company client. Their own working papers are usually theirs to keep.
Do I need my old accountant's permission to change accountant?
No. You can appoint a new accountant at any time. The new firm sends a professional enquiry to the old one as a standard professional step, but the old accountant cannot block the move, and the new one can be authorised with HMRC without their agreement.
Will HMRC cancel penalties because my accountant did not file?
Possibly. HMRC lists relying on someone else to send your return, when they did not, as something that may be a reasonable excuse. By law it only counts if you also took reasonable care yourself, such as chasing progress, and the return must be filed as soon as you are able.
Can Companies House give me more time because my accountant let me down?
Unlikely. Companies House only extends an accounts deadline for an event outside your control, such as an unexpected illness or a fire destroying records, and you must apply before the deadline. Accountant problems are not among its examples.
How much does it cost to catch up after a bad accountant?
At Your Tax Help Accountants it is one fixed project fee agreed in writing before we start, typically £400 to £10,000 depending on how many years and returns are outstanding and how much has to be rebuilt.
We take over and put it right
Your Tax Help Accountants is an HMRC-registered practice at 79 College Road, Harrow, helping clients UK-wide. We take over from accountants who have let clients down, rebuild missing records and bring every overdue return up to date for one fixed fee.
Or email info@yourtaxhelp.co.uk | Book a free 15-minute call
General guidance only. Not personal tax advice. Contact us for advice specific to your situation. All figures are for the 2026/27 tax year unless otherwise stated.
