Self Assessment · Refunds
Overpayment Relief: How to Claim Back Tax Overpaid in Earlier Years (4-Year Rule)
Quick answer: if you paid too much Income Tax or Capital Gains Tax in an earlier year and it is too late to amend that return, you can usually claim it back with an overpayment relief claim. It must be made in writing, say it is a claim for overpayment relief, and reach HMRC within 4 years of the end of the tax year. For 2022/23 that means by 5 April 2027.
Found a mistake in an old tax return? Forgot to claim expenses, double counted income, or paid tax you never owed? If the 12-month window to amend the return has closed, the money is not necessarily lost. This guide explains how overpayment relief works, the deadlines, what the letter must say and when HMRC can refuse.
Within 12 months of the filing deadline, amend the return online. After that, write to HMRC with an overpayment relief claim within 4 years of the end of the tax year. State the year, the amount, why it is wrong, whether you appealed before, and sign the declaration yourself.
First: can you still amend the return?
The simplest fix is an amendment, which you can make up to 12 months after the 31 January filing deadline. Our guide on how to correct a mistake on a filed tax return explains that route. Overpayment relief is for when that window has closed.
Which route applies today (20 November 2026)
| 2025/26 | Amend online until 31 January 2028 |
| 2024/25 | Amend online until 31 January 2027 |
| 2023/24 | Amendment window closed. Overpayment relief claim by 5 April 2028 |
| 2022/23 | Amendment window closed. Overpayment relief claim by 5 April 2027 |
| 2021/22 and earlier | Usually out of time for a claim |
What an overpayment relief claim must include
HMRC’s own manual sets out what a valid claim needs. It cannot be made by putting it in a tax return, it must be a separate claim in writing, and it must:
- clearly state that it is a claim for overpayment relief
- identify the tax year concerned
- explain the grounds, meaning why you paid too much
- say whether you have appealed before about the same payment or assessment
- state the amount you believe you overpaid
- include a signed declaration by you, not your agent, that the details are correct and complete to the best of your knowledge and belief
Keep the evidence, such as receipts, P60s or bank statements, because HMRC may ask for it. HMRC’s manual gives the address for Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax claims as PAYE Self-Assessment, HM Revenue and Customs, BX9 1AS.
Expenses missed on a 2022/23 return
Lena is a self-employed hairdresser. In 2026 she realises her 2022/23 return left out £2,000 of products and training costs. She was a basic-rate taxpayer that year. The amendment window for 2022/23 closed on 31 January 2025, so she makes an overpayment relief claim instead, before 5 April 2027.
The extra £2,000 of expenses reduces her taxable profit, which saves £400 of Income Tax at 20%, plus the Class 4 National Insurance that was charged on that profit. Her claim states the year, the reason, the amount, that she has not appealed before, and she signs the declaration.
Running out of time on an old year? We can check it and draft the claim for you.
📅 Book a Free 15-Min CallHMRC-registered agent · Fixed fees · We deal with HMRC for you
When HMRC can refuse a claim
The law lists cases where relief is not given. In plain terms, HMRC can refuse if:
- you could have fixed it another way in time, for example by amending the return or making a different claim or election, and simply did not
- the point has already been decided on an appeal, or you could have appealed and did not
- the mistake was in making, or not making, a claim or election, for example capital allowances
- the tax was worked out in line with the practice generally followed at the time
- HMRC is already taking proceedings to recover the tax
Relying on the 4-year limit is risky. It is a hard deadline, and HMRC’s view of a claim can take months, so do not leave it to the last week.
Employees and pensioners
If you are not in Self Assessment, many earlier-year overpayments are fixed without a formal overpayment relief letter. Work expenses can be claimed for the previous 4 years through HMRC’s online service (see our P87 work expenses guide), tax on savings interest through an R40, and PAYE errors often through a P800 calculation. Our refund timescales guide explains how long each route takes.
What about tax you underpaid?
The time limits work in HMRC’s favour too: it can usually go back 4 years, longer if the error was careless or deliberate. If an old return has a mistake that went the other way, see how far back HMRC can go before you write to them.
Free · No obligation
Think an old return was wrong?
Tell us which year and what happened. We reply the same day with whether you can still claim and a fixed fee.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is overpayment relief?
It is a way to claim back Income Tax, Capital Gains Tax or Class 4 National Insurance you paid but did not owe, when it is too late to amend the return. It is made in writing to HMRC.
How far back can I claim overpaid tax?
Generally 4 years from the end of the tax year. For 2022/23 the deadline is 5 April 2027, and for 2023/24 it is 5 April 2028.
Can I make an overpayment relief claim on my tax return?
No. HMRC will not accept a claim included in a tax return. It must be a separate written claim that says it is a claim for overpayment relief.
Can my accountant sign the claim?
Your accountant can prepare it, but the declaration must be signed by you, not by your agent.
Why would HMRC refuse a claim?
For example if you could have fixed it in time by amending the return or making another claim, if the point was settled on appeal, or if the tax was worked out in line with practice generally followed at the time.
Old returns reviewed, claims made
Your Tax Help Accountants is an HMRC-registered practice at 79 College Road, Harrow, helping clients UK-wide. We review earlier tax returns, find where tax was overpaid and prepare amendments or overpayment relief claims for a fixed fee agreed up front.
Or email info@yourtaxhelp.co.uk | Book a free 15-minute call
General guidance only. Not personal tax advice. Contact us for advice specific to your situation. All figures are for the 2026/27 tax year unless otherwise stated.
