Quick answer: pension providers usually tax your first flexible withdrawal on an emergency month 1 code, so you can pay thousands too much. Use P55 if you took part of your pot and will not take more this tax year; P53Z if you emptied the pot and have other income or will work again; P50Z if you emptied the pot, have stopped work and have no other taxable income apart from State Pension. Small pots use P53. Claiming now means the refund usually arrives within weeks, instead of waiting for HMRC's check after the tax year ends.
Since pension freedoms began in 2015, people aged 55 and over (rising to 57 from April 2028) can take money from a defined contribution pension when they like. The first 25% is usually tax-free. The rest is taxed as income, and that is where the problem starts.
Why Pension Withdrawals Are Overtaxed
When you make your first taxable withdrawal, the provider usually does not have an up-to-date tax code for you, so it uses an emergency code on a month 1 basis. That treats the payment as if you will receive the same amount every month for the whole year. One large withdrawal is taxed as if you were earning twelve times as much, which pushes much of it into the 40% and 45% bands.
A £20,000 withdrawal with no other income this year
Sam takes £20,000 from a £60,000 pot. £5,000 (25%) is tax-free, so £15,000 is taxable. On an emergency code 1257L month 1, the provider gives just one month of personal allowance (£1,047.50) and one month of each tax band. The tax taken is about £5,181.
If Sam has no other income this tax year, the correct tax is about £486 (£15,000 less the £12,570 personal allowance, taxed at 20%). Sam has overpaid about £4,695, and can claim it back now on form P55 instead of waiting until the end of the tax year.
Which Form Do I Need?
- P55: you took part of your pension pot (it is not empty), and you will not take any more regular or flexible payments before the end of the tax year.
- P53Z: you emptied your pension pot and you have other income, such as a job, or you expect to work again. Also used for serious ill-health lump sums.
- P50Z: you emptied your pension pot, you have stopped working and do not expect to work again, and you have no other taxable income except the State Pension. Wait until at least 4 weeks after you stopped work or received the payment, and do not use it if you claim a taxable state benefit or expect a new job within 4 weeks.
- P53: you took a small pot or trivial commutation lump sum.
You can claim online through GOV.UK or by post. You will need the P45 or payment statement from your pension provider, showing the amount paid and tax taken.
How to Claim, Step by Step
- Get the payment details from your provider: gross amount, tax-free part, and tax deducted. Ask for a P45 if you emptied the pot.
- Pick the right form using the list above.
- Fill in your expected income for the whole tax year, including State Pension, any job and any other pensions. Be realistic: HMRC uses this to work out your refund.
- Submit online through your Government Gateway account, or post it.
- Wait for the refund. HMRC works out the repayment and pays it to you, usually within weeks of a correct claim. It checks the figures again after the tax year ends and will contact you if your income was different.
What If I Do Nothing?
If you do not claim, HMRC should normally sort it out after the tax year ends, through a P800 calculation or your tax return if you file one. That can mean waiting a year or more for money that is yours. If you are in Self Assessment, the overpayment can be dealt with on your return instead of a separate form.
Watch Out for Later Withdrawals
After the first payment, HMRC sends your provider a proper tax code. Future withdrawals should be taxed more accurately, but check each payslip from the provider. If you take another large lump sum in a later tax year, the emergency code can be used again. For more on how pensions are taxed, see tax on pension income and the tax-free pension lump sum.
The Bottom Line
If you took cash from your pension and a large chunk went in tax, you have probably been taxed on an emergency code. Choose P55, P53Z or P50Z depending on whether you emptied your pot and whether you have other income, and claim it back now rather than waiting until after the tax year.
Frequently Asked Questions
Lost too much tax on a pension withdrawal?
We check what you should have paid, complete the right form with you, and make sure the refund reaches you. Free first check, fixed fees after that.
Or email info@yourtaxhelp.co.uk | yourtaxhelp.co.uk
Related guides: Tax on pension income · Tax-free lump sum · Claim back emergency tax
Free · No obligation
Want us to check your specific situation?
Send us a few details and we'll review them ourselves, then come back to you with what we'd check or change. Free, and no obligation.
