Quick answer: most errors fall into four groups. Sign-in: wrong Government Gateway ID or a temporary lock after failed attempts (wait and retry, or recover your ID). Self Assessment not showing: add it as a service and use the posted activation code within 28 days. Return will not submit: a figure fails HMRC's checks; note the exact error number and box. "Cannot be filed online": your situation is an HMRC filing exclusion, so file on paper with a note, which HMRC accepts by 31 January. Keep screenshots: they support an appeal if the error makes you late.
Nothing is more frustrating than doing your tax return and then being stopped by an error at the last step, often in the last week of January. Here are the problems we see most, and how to get past them.
1. Sign-in and Account Errors
"Your user ID or password is incorrect" or your account is locked
After several wrong attempts, the account is locked for a short time. Wait, then try again, or use the "forgotten your user ID or password" option. Many people have more than one Government Gateway ID; if Self Assessment is attached to the other one, you will not see it.
Self Assessment is not listed in your account
Add Self Assessment as a service. HMRC posts an activation code, which usually arrives within 10 working days and expires after 28 days. Without it you cannot file online, so act early. See UTR not received or not working.
2. UTR Errors
"UTR not recognised" usually means a typo, adding the letter K from the payment reference, or entering a company UTR instead of your personal one. If HMRC has closed or locked your record, only HMRC can reopen it; call the Self Assessment helpline.
3. The Return Will Not Submit
If the return is complete but will not file, HMRC's system has rejected a figure. Common causes:
- a box left blank that needs a 0, or a total that does not match its parts
- employment details that do not match the employer's PAYE reference format
- pages ticked in the first section but not completed, or completed but not ticked
- a calculation mismatch, such as error 6492, where the tax figure in the calculation does not agree with HMRC's own
Write down the exact error number and wording, check the box it points to, and if it still fails contact HMRC's online services helpdesk. If you use commercial software, its support team will often know the error.
4. "Your Return Cannot Be Filed Online"
Some unusual combinations of income and reliefs cannot be calculated by HMRC's online service or some software. HMRC publishes these each year as special cases or exclusions. If yours is one, you file a paper return with a note explaining it is an excluded case, and HMRC accepts it as on time if it arrives by 31 January, not the usual 31 October paper deadline.
5. Payment and Penalty Errors
When paying, use your UTR followed by K as the reference (for example 1234567890K). A wrong reference means the payment may not be matched and HMRC may send reminders or charge interest. If the error relates to a penalty you think is unfair, see how to appeal an HMRC penalty.
What If an Error Makes You Late?
Take screenshots of each error with the date and time, and note any calls to HMRC with the date and reference. An HMRC system problem that stopped you filing, which you tried to fix promptly, can be a reasonable excuse for a late filing penalty. File as soon as the problem is fixed.
Example: a landlord blocked on 30 January
Imagine a landlord whose return keeps being rejected with a calculation error on 30 January. With screenshots taken, a note of the call to HMRC, and the return filed through agent software or on paper as soon as possible, he has good evidence if a £100 penalty is issued, and a strong appeal.
The Bottom Line
Most Self Assessment errors are about sign-in, a missing activation code, a UTR mix-up or a figure HMRC's checks do not accept. Start early so there is time to fix them, keep evidence of every error, and if the deadline is close, let an accountant file through agent software instead.
Frequently Asked Questions
Fed up with HMRC's online errors?
Send us your records and we file your return through our agent software, deal with any rejections, and keep you on time. Fixed fee, Express 48-hour option.
Or email info@yourtaxhelp.co.uk | yourtaxhelp.co.uk
Related guides: Missed the deadline? · Appeal a penalty · Self Assessment accountant
Free · No obligation
Want us to check your specific situation?
Send us a few details and we'll review them ourselves, then come back to you with what we'd check or change. Free, and no obligation.
