Self Assessment | Tax Debt
HMRC Says You Owe Tax You Cannot Pay: How Time to Pay Actually Works
Quick answer: Time to Pay lets you clear a tax debt in instalments, usually monthly by direct debit. If you owe under £30,000, are within 60 days of the deadline and have filed all returns, you can set up a plan online for up to 12 months; otherwise call 0300 200 3822. Interest keeps running, but agreeing a plan before the first 5% late payment penalty at 30 days avoids the penalties.
The return is filed, the number is bigger than you expected, and the money is not there. This is the point at which a lot of people stop opening the post. It is worth knowing that HMRC arranges hundreds of thousands of payment plans a year, that asking for one is routine rather than an admission of failure, and that almost every bad outcome in this area comes from silence rather than from the debt itself.
If you would rather hand this to someone, see our Self Assessment accountant service, or see our late tax returns service.
The short version: if you owe less than £30,000, are within 60 days of the deadline and have filed all your returns, you can usually set up a payment plan online in minutes without speaking to anyone. Above £30,000, you phone.
What Time to Pay Actually Is
A Time to Pay arrangement is a formal agreement to clear a tax debt in instalments, normally monthly by direct debit, instead of in one lump on the due date. It is not a write-off, a reduction, or a negotiation about how much tax you owe. The amount does not change. What changes is when you pay it, and crucially, whether late payment penalties apply.
HMRC would rather collect in instalments than not collect at all, which is why the process is far less adversarial than people expect. If you can show the debt is real, your figures are filed, and you can afford the instalments you are proposing, agreement is usually straightforward.
Every Route to Set One Up
- Online, self-serve (easiest). Sign into your HMRC online account and set up a Self Assessment payment plan. You are eligible if you owe less than £30,000, are within 60 days of the payment deadline, have filed all outstanding returns, and have no other payment plans or debts with HMRC. You choose the instalments, up to 12 months, and it is agreed on the spot. No phone call, no means test.
- By phone. If you owe more than £30,000, need longer than 12 months, or have missed the 60-day window, call the Self Assessment Payment Helpline on 0300 200 3822. Expect questions about income, outgoings, savings and assets. Have the figures ready, because a vague call gets a vague outcome.
- Through your accountant. An authorised agent can discuss the debt and negotiate terms with HMRC on your behalf. This is worth it for larger or messier debts, where several years or several taxes are involved.
What It Costs: Interest Keeps Running
Be clear on this, because it is the most misunderstood part. A Time to Pay arrangement does not stop interest. Late payment interest continues to accrue on the outstanding balance for the whole life of the plan, currently at 7.75 per cent from 9 January 2026.
What it does stop is the late payment penalties, which are the genuinely painful part. For Self Assessment those are charged at 5 per cent of the tax still unpaid 30 days after the due date, another 5 per cent at six months, and another 5 per cent at twelve months. On a £10,000 bill left alone for a year, that is £1,500 in penalties on top of the interest. Agree a plan before the 30-day point and you avoid all of it.
The single highest-value action is agreeing the plan before the first 5 per cent penalty bites, 30 days after the due date. Everything after that is damage limitation.
Dealing with this yourself? We can take it off your plate.
📅 Book a Free 15-Min CallHMRC-registered agent · Fixed fees · We deal with HMRC for you
Free · No obligation
Want us to check your specific situation?
Send us a few details and we’ll review them ourselves, then come back to you with what we’d check or change. Free, and no obligation.
What HMRC Will Ask You
For a phone arrangement, HMRC is deciding whether your proposal is realistic. Expect to be asked about your income and how regular it is, your essential outgoings, what you hold in savings or could readily realise, why you cannot pay now, and what you can commit to monthly.
Two pieces of practical advice. First, propose a figure you can genuinely sustain, not the most heroic number you can imagine, because a defaulted arrangement is much harder to renegotiate than a modest one is to accelerate. Second, if the reason for the shortfall is a one-off, say so plainly. HMRC responds better to a specific explanation than to a general plea.
If the Bill Itself Looks Wrong
Before you agree to pay anything, check the number is right. Two situations are extremely common and both reduce the debt rather than reschedule it.
- Payments on account you no longer need. If your income has fallen, the payments on account HMRC is demanding may be based on a better year. They can be formally reduced, which cuts the bill immediately rather than spreading it.
- A determination, not a real return. If you did not file, HMRC may have estimated the tax itself. That estimate is usually higher than the truth. Filing the actual return displaces the determination and often removes most of the debt.
- Expenses never claimed. First-time filers routinely miss mileage, use of home, tools, insurance and professional fees. A review of the return can change the liability itself.
What Happens If You Do Nothing
This is the section that matters most. HMRC does not forget, and the escalation is predictable: interest accrues daily, the three 5 per cent penalties land at 30 days, six months and twelve months, and the debt moves to HMRC debt management. From there it can go to a private debt collection agency, or HMRC can use its own powers, which include taking the money directly from your bank account, deducting it through your tax code if you are employed, sending enforcement officers to take control of goods, or in serious cases petitioning for bankruptcy.
Almost none of that happens to people who pick up the phone. HMRC is markedly more accommodating to someone who contacts it before the deadline than to someone it has had to chase for a year. The debt is the same either way. The treatment is not.
£18,400 bill, no cash, and a plan agreed in one call
Client J, a self-employed contractor, filed his return in January and faced a bill of £18,400, made up of the balancing payment for the year plus his first payment on account. He had had a strong year followed by a very quiet autumn, and the money had gone into a van and a quiet three months. He had not opened the last two letters when he came to us.
We did two things. First we reduced his payments on account, because his current year income was clearly running well below the previous year, which took roughly £4,900 off the immediate demand. Then we agreed a Time to Pay arrangement over ten months on the remaining balance. Because we acted 11 days before the 30-day penalty point, he avoided the first 5 per cent charge entirely, worth about £675, and the two later ones. He paid interest at the prevailing rate and nothing else, and the arrangement ran to completion.
Related reading: Missed the Self Assessment Deadline? HMRC Penalties Explained (UK 2026) and Behind on Tax Returns? A Hendon Catch-Up Guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I set up a payment plan with HMRC online?
Yes, if you owe less than £30,000, are within 60 days of the payment deadline, have filed all your outstanding returns and have no other HMRC payment plans or debts. You can spread it over up to 12 months and it is agreed instantly, with no phone call.
Does HMRC charge interest on a Time to Pay arrangement?
Yes. Late payment interest continues to run on the outstanding balance throughout the plan, currently 7.75 per cent from 9 January 2026. What a plan prevents is the late payment penalties, which are 5 per cent of the unpaid tax at 30 days, six months and twelve months.
What happens if I ignore a tax bill I cannot pay?
Interest accrues daily and three separate 5 per cent penalties are charged at 30 days, six months and twelve months. The debt then passes to HMRC debt management, which can use a debt collection agency, take money directly from your bank account, collect through your tax code, or send enforcement officers.
Will HMRC reduce the amount of tax I owe?
Time to Pay changes when you pay, not how much. However the bill itself may genuinely be wrong: payments on account can often be reduced if your income has fallen, a determination raised because you did not file can be displaced by filing the real return, and unclaimed expenses can reduce the liability. Check the number before agreeing to pay it.
What phone number do I call about a tax bill I cannot pay?
The Self Assessment Payment Helpline is 0300 200 3822. Use this if you owe more than £30,000, need longer than 12 months, or have missed the 60-day self-serve window. Have your income, outgoings and a realistic monthly figure ready before you call.
Tax bill you cannot pay? Talk to us before the penalties start.
At Your Tax Help Accountants in Harrow, we check whether the bill is right, reduce payments on account where income has fallen, and negotiate Time to Pay arrangements with HMRC for clients across London and the UK. No judgement, and the sooner you call the more we can do.
Or email info@yourtaxhelp.co.uk | Get help with an HMRC payment plan
General guidance only. Not personal tax advice. Contact us for advice specific to your situation. All figures are for the 2026/27 tax year unless otherwise stated.
