Payroll | Small Business
Employing Your First Employee: The Full Checklist (and What It Really Costs)
Quick answer: before your first employee starts, check their right to work, give a written statement on or before day one, register for PAYE, arrange employers' liability insurance with at least £5 million of cover, and set up pension auto-enrolment. Budget roughly 20 to 25 per cent above the salary for the true cost. Remember to claim the Employment Allowance, worth up to £10,500, as it is not applied automatically.
Hiring your first person is the point at which a business stops being just you, and it is also the point at which five separate sets of rules land at once. Most people know about PAYE. Fewer know that a written contract is a day-one right, that employers’ liability insurance is a criminal requirement, or that the pension duties start automatically without anyone writing to you. None of it is difficult, but it is easy to miss a piece.
If you would rather hand this to someone, see our payroll services, or see our guide to registering as an employer.
The short version: check their right to work before they start, give a written statement on or before day one, register for PAYE, arrange employers’ liability insurance, and set up pension auto-enrolment. Budget roughly 20 to 25 per cent above the salary for the true cost.
1. Check Their Right to Work (Before They Start)
This must be done before the first day of work, not afterwards, and it applies to every single employee including British citizens. Checking only people you think might need it is discrimination.
There are three valid methods: a manual check of original documents with the person present, an online check using a share code for those with digital status, or an identity service provider using certified technology for British and Irish passport holders. Keep a dated copy for the duration of employment and two years afterwards.
Get this right and you have a statutory excuse against a civil penalty. Get it wrong and penalties for illegal working run to tens of thousands of pounds per worker. It takes ten minutes and it is the single highest-risk item on the list to skip.
2. Give a Written Statement on or Before Day One
A written statement of employment particulars is a day-one right. The old two-month grace period is long gone. It must cover pay, hours, holiday entitlement, place of work, job title, start date, notice periods, probation, sick pay, and any training entitlement.
A proper contract does more than satisfy the rule. It sets the probationary period, defines notice, and protects your client relationships and confidential information. The cost of having one drafted once, then reused, is trivial against the cost of a dispute with no written terms.
3. Register for PAYE and Set Up Payroll
Register with HMRC before the first payday, allowing around five working days for the employer reference. You will need payroll software to file Real Time Information on or before each payday, and you will deduct income tax and employee National Insurance, then pay HMRC by the 22nd of the following month.
The full registration process is covered in our guide to registering as an employer with HMRC. You will also need a P45 from their previous employer, or a starter checklist if they do not have one, to put them on the right tax code from the outset.
4. Employers’ Liability Insurance (This One Is Criminal Law)
You are legally required to hold employers’ liability insurance with a minimum of £5 million of cover from the day your first employee starts, from an authorised insurer. The fine for not holding it is up to £2,500 for every day you are uninsured, and a further penalty applies for failing to display or produce the certificate on request.
There is a narrow exemption for some companies whose only employee is a sole director owning more than half the share capital, which is why one-person companies often do not hold it. The moment you take on anyone else, that exemption falls away.
The Employment Allowance is worth up to £10,500 against your employer National Insurance, but it is not applied automatically. It has to be claimed each year through your payroll software, and a great many first-time employers simply never tick the box.
Dealing with this yourself? We can take it off your plate.
📅 Book a Free 15-Min CallHMRC-registered agent · Fixed fees · We deal with HMRC for you
Free · No obligation
Want us to check your specific situation?
Send us a few details and we’ll review them ourselves, then come back to you with what we’d check or change. Free, and no obligation.
5. Pension Auto-Enrolment (It Starts Automatically)
This surprises people more than anything else on the list. Your automatic enrolment duties begin on the day your first member of staff starts. Nobody has to write to you first, and there is no opt-in.
- You must assess the employee. Anyone aged 22 to State Pension age earning over £10,000 a year must be automatically enrolled.
- You must set up a pension scheme that meets the auto-enrolment rules and enrol them.
- Minimum total contributions are 8 per cent of earnings in the auto-enrolment band, of which at least 3 per cent must come from you as the employer.
- You must write to the employee explaining their rights within six weeks.
- You must complete a declaration of compliance with The Pensions Regulator within five months of your duties starting. This is a separate task from enrolling them and it is the one most commonly forgotten.
- Even if the employee earns under the threshold or opts out, you still have duties and you still must complete the declaration.
The Pensions Regulator issues fixed penalties of £400 followed by daily escalating penalties for non-compliance, and it does enforce them against very small employers.
What It Actually Costs, Above the Salary
Budget realistically. On top of gross pay you will pay employer National Insurance at 15 per cent on earnings above £5,000 a year, employer pension contributions of at least 3 per cent, employers’ liability insurance, payroll software or a payroll service, and holiday: a full-time employee is entitled to 5.6 weeks of paid leave, which is 28 days including bank holidays for a five-day week.
The one significant offset is the Employment Allowance, worth up to £10,500 against your employer National Insurance bill. Most small employers taking on their first employee are eligible, and it must be claimed through your payroll software rather than being applied automatically. For a first hire on a modest salary it frequently wipes out the employer National Insurance entirely.
As a working figure, allow 20 to 25 per cent above the gross salary before the Employment Allowance, and recalculate once you know whether you can claim it.
What Happens If You Skip a Step
- No right to work check: civil penalties per illegal worker running to tens of thousands of pounds, and no statutory excuse.
- No written statement: compensation of two to four weeks’ pay if the employee brings another successful claim, and a much weaker position in any dispute.
- Late PAYE registration: backdated tax and National Insurance, interest and late filing penalties.
- No employers’ liability insurance: up to £2,500 per day uninsured, plus personal exposure if someone is injured.
- Missed auto-enrolment: £400 fixed penalty, then daily escalating penalties, plus backdated contributions including the employee’s share.
None of these are common because the rules are obscure. They are common because a first hire usually happens when the business is busiest, and the paperwork gets deferred. Doing it in the fortnight before the start date, rather than the month after, removes essentially all of the risk.
A first hire that went smoothly, and the £3,900 that was nearly missed
Client B ran a growing plumbing business alone and took on his first employee, an apprentice on £22,000. He had budgeted for the salary and nothing else, and had assumed the pension was something he would look at "next year". He had also not heard of the Employment Allowance.
We set the scheme up two weeks before the start date: PAYE registration, payroll software, a written statement, a right to work check and a pension scheme that meets the auto-enrolment rules, with the declaration of compliance filed. His employer National Insurance on £22,000 would have been around £2,550 for the year, and we claimed the Employment Allowance, which removed it entirely. Together with correcting the pension position before any penalty arose, the setup was worth close to £3,900 in the first year against a payroll fee of a few hundred pounds. The point is not that we were clever, it is that the allowance has to be claimed and the pension has to be dealt with on day one, and neither happens by itself.
Related reading: P11D and Benefits in Kind Explained for Employers and Directors (2026).
Frequently Asked Questions
What do I legally need to do before hiring my first employee?
Five things: check their right to work before they start, give a written statement of employment particulars on or before day one, register for PAYE with HMRC before the first payday, arrange employers liability insurance with at least £5 million of cover, and set up pension auto-enrolment.
Do I need employers liability insurance for one employee?
Yes. It is a legal requirement from the day your first employee starts, with a minimum of £5 million of cover from an authorised insurer. The fine is up to £2,500 for every day you are uninsured. A narrow exemption applies to some single-director companies, but it falls away the moment you employ anyone else.
Do I have to set up a pension for my first employee?
Yes. Automatic enrolment duties start on the day your first member of staff begins work, without anyone contacting you. Employees aged 22 to State Pension age earning over £10,000 must be enrolled, with minimum total contributions of 8 per cent of earnings in the auto-enrolment band, at least 3 per cent from you. You must also file a declaration of compliance with The Pensions Regulator within five months.
How much does an employee actually cost above their salary?
As a working figure, allow 20 to 25 per cent above gross salary: employer National Insurance at 15 per cent above £5,000 a year, employer pension contributions of at least 3 per cent, employers liability insurance and payroll costs. The Employment Allowance of up to £10,500 can offset the employer National Insurance entirely for a first hire on a modest salary.
When must I give an employment contract?
A written statement of employment particulars is a day-one right, so it must be given on or before the first day of work. It must cover pay, hours, holiday, place of work, job title, start date, notice, probation, sick pay and training entitlement.
Taking on your first employee? Get the setup right first time.
At Your Tax Help Accountants in Harrow, we set up first-time employers across London and the UK: PAYE registration, payroll software, auto-enrolment and the Employment Allowance claim. Fixed monthly fee, and we make sure nothing on the checklist is missed.
Or email info@yourtaxhelp.co.uk | Get help employing your first employee
General guidance only. Not personal tax advice. Contact us for advice specific to your situation. All figures are for the 2026/27 tax year unless otherwise stated.
