Quick answer: first work out which letter it is from the code in the corner. A P800 usually means underpaid PAYE tax, often collected through your tax code if under £3,000. A PA302 Simple Assessment is a bill you pay directly, normally by 31 January, and you have 60 days to query it. A Self Assessment statement or penalty notice relates to your tax return. Check the figures before you pay; HMRC letters are often based on information from employers or banks that can be wrong.
A brown envelope from HMRC saying you owe money is stressful, especially if you are employed and thought your tax was sorted through PAYE. The good news is that most of these letters are routine, many can be paid in instalments, and some are simply wrong.
Step 1: Check the Letter Is Genuine
Scammers copy HMRC letters, texts and emails. HMRC will not ask for bank details by email or text, or threaten arrest. A real letter can be checked against your HMRC personal tax account, where the same amount should appear. If in doubt, sign in yourself rather than using any link or number in the message.
Step 2: Find Out Which Letter You Have
HMRC prints a form code in the bottom corner of most letters. These are the ones that say you owe tax:
- P800 tax calculation: for employees and pensioners. It compares the tax you should have paid with what PAYE took. If you underpaid by less than £3,000 and still have a job or pension, HMRC usually collects it by changing your tax code next year rather than asking for a lump sum. See our P800 guide.
- PA302 Simple Assessment: a bill for tax HMRC could not collect through PAYE, often on the State Pension, savings interest or a large underpayment. You normally pay by 31 January after the tax year, or within 3 months of the letter if it was issued later. See our PA302 guide.
- Self Assessment statement: shows the balance on your tax return account, including payments on account due on 31 January and 31 July.
- Penalty notice (often SA326D): a late filing penalty, starting at £100. These can be appealed if you had a reasonable excuse.
- Debt collection or "pay now" letters: sent when an earlier bill was not paid. Act quickly; see HMRC debt collection letters.
Step 3: Check the Figures
HMRC builds these calculations from what employers, pension providers and banks report. Common mistakes we see:
- a job you left still showing as current, so income is counted twice
- the wrong amount of savings interest, or interest on an ISA counted as taxable
- a company car or medical insurance that ended but is still on your record
- work expenses, pension contributions or Gift Aid you are entitled to claim but have not
- the State Pension figure for the wrong year
Compare the income shown with your P60s, P45s and bank interest statements. If something is wrong, tell HMRC. For a PA302 you have 60 days from the date of the letter to query it.
Step 4: Pay, Spread or Dispute
If it is right and you can pay
Pay by the date on the letter using the payment reference shown. Late payment interest is charged at the Bank of England base rate plus 4%, so paying on time matters.
If it is right but you cannot pay in one go
You can often set up a payment plan online. For Self Assessment debts of £30,000 or less you can usually set one up yourself without calling. See can't pay your tax bill? Time to Pay explained. If you are employed, you can also ask HMRC to collect a smaller underpayment through your tax code.
If it is wrong
Contact HMRC with the correct figures and copies of your evidence. Do not ignore the letter: if you are disputing it, say so in writing before the payment date so it is on record.
Example: a £1,900 PA302 that should have been much smaller
Imagine a retired teacher who receives a Simple Assessment for £1,900. Checking it against her P60s shows that her pension provider reported a lump sum twice when she moved schemes. By writing to HMRC with the P60s within the 60-day window, the bill is recalculated on her real income, leaving only the tax on her savings interest.
The Bottom Line
Identify the letter from its code, check it is genuine, then check the figures before paying. Most bills can be spread, and a surprising number are wrong. The one thing not to do is ignore it, because interest and penalties keep growing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Got an HMRC letter you do not understand?
Send us a photo and we will tell you what it means, whether it is right, and what to do next. If we need to deal with HMRC for you, we quote a fixed fee first.
Or email info@yourtaxhelp.co.uk | yourtaxhelp.co.uk
Related guides: P800 explained · PA302 Simple Assessment · Can't pay your tax bill?
Free · No obligation
Want us to check your specific situation?
Send us a few details and we'll review them ourselves, then come back to you with what we'd check or change. Free, and no obligation.
